Guides

Stainless vs. aluminum vs. galvanized vs. nylon dock cleats

Each material is the right answer somewhere. The trick is matching it to your water, your dock and your boat.

Most dock and boat cleats are made from one of four materials: stainless steel, aluminum, galvanized iron or steel, and nylon. Here's how they compare and where each one makes sense.

At a glance

StrengthCorrosionWeightPrice
Stainless steelVery highExcellent (316 grade)Heavy$$$
AluminumGoodVery goodLight$$
Galvanized iron or steelVery highFair; coating wearsHeavy$
NylonLow to moderateWon't corrodeVery light$

Stainless steel

The strongest and best-looking option, and the standard on boat decks. For salt water, look for 316 stainless, which resists pitting and rust staining better than 304. Investment-cast stainless cleats are solid and smooth, so they're kind to lines.

Choose it for: boats, salt water, high-load spots and anywhere looks matter. Watch out for: price, and weight on small boats.

Aluminum

The most common choice for docks. Aluminum is light, doesn't rust, and comes in polished, matte, black and white finishes. It's softer than steel, so heavy boats or surge-prone slips call for a bigger cleat than you'd pick in stainless.

Choose it for: wood, aluminum and floating docks in fresh or salt water. Watch out for: mixing it with stainless or galvanized fasteners in salt water without isolation (see below).

Galvanized iron or steel

Cast iron or steel dipped in zinc. It's cheap and very strong, which is why it's everywhere on fixed wooden docks and commercial piers. The zinc coating protects the metal underneath, but it wears away over the years, especially in salt water, and then rust follows.

Choose it for: budget dock builds, fresh water, and heavy-duty spots where looks don't matter. Watch out for: rust streaks on decking once the coating wears, and rough castings that chafe lines.

Nylon

Injection-molded and UV-stabilized. Nylon won't corrode, scratch the boat or get hot in the sun, and it costs very little. It's not as strong as metal, so keep it to small boats, kayaks, tenders and light-duty jobs.

Choose it for: small boats, PWCs, kayak docks and fender lines. Watch out for: heavy boats and shock loads.

Mixing metals: galvanic corrosion

When two different metals touch in salt water, the less noble one corrodes faster. The classic problem is stainless bolts through an aluminum cleat or dock. You can reduce it by using nylon or plastic isolating washers, coating fasteners with an anti-seize or isolating compound made for marine use, and keeping like with like where you can: stainless bolts with stainless cleats, galvanized with galvanized.

Quick picks

  • Salt water boat deck: 316 stainless.
  • Floating or aluminum dock: aluminum.
  • Fixed wooden dock on a budget: galvanized, sized up a step.
  • Kayak or small-boat dock: nylon or small aluminum.

Not sure about size? Start with the sizing guide.

Next guide: Flip-up vs. pull-up vs. pop-up cleats compared