Cleats rarely break. What usually happens is the fasteners loosen, the wood around them rots or splits, and one day a hard pull takes the cleat, and sometimes a chunk of deck board, with it. If a cleat moves when you tug on it, or there's rust bleeding from the base, it's time to deal with it.
Why cleats come loose
- Lag screws instead of through-bolts. Screws into a single board work loose as the wood swells and shrinks.
- No backing block. All the load sits on a small patch of decking.
- Rot around the holes. Unsealed holes let water into the wood, which softens and lets go.
- Corrosion. Galvanized cleats and fasteners rust once the zinc wears off; mixed metals corrode faster in salt water.
- Too small a cleat for the boat, so every gust shock-loads it.
Removing the old cleat
- Take the lines off and check what's underneath. If there are nuts below the decking, hold them with a wrench while you turn the bolts.
- Rusted bolts: soak them in penetrating oil, give it time, and try again. If they won't move, cut them with an oscillating tool or a hacksaw under the deck.
- Lag screws: back them out. If they spin in rotten wood, pry the cleat up gently and pull them.
Repairing the wood
- Sound wood with stripped holes: fill the holes with epoxy or glued hardwood dowels, let them cure, and re-drill.
- Soft or split boards: replace the board. A new cleat in rotten wood won't hold any better than the old one.
- Move it if you need to. Shifting the cleat a few inches to fresh wood, ideally where a backing block can reach the joists, is often easier than repairing in place.
Installing the replacement
Size the new cleat to your line (see the sizing guide), then through-bolt it with a backing block underneath, washers, lock nuts and sealant in the holes. The full steps are in how to install a dock cleat.
If the old bolt pattern is still good, look for a replacement with the same hole spacing. Many cleat pages in the database list fastener sizes and hole spacing so you can match them.
Upgrade while you're at it
- Swap galvanized for aluminum or 316 stainless if rust was the problem.
- Go a size larger if the old cleat was crowded by the line.
- Consider a flip-up cleat if people trip over it.
Replacement cleats that resist rust
- Attwood Fold-Down Dock Cleat 8in8" · ~1/2" line · Aluminum
- Dock Edge Flip-Up Dock Cleat 8in Polished8" · ~1/2" line · Almag 35 aluminum
- Pacific Marine & Industrial Aluminum Dock Cleat 8in8" · ~1/2" line · Aluminum
- Sea-Dog Heavy Duty Open Base Cleat 8in8" · ~1/2" line · 316 stainless steel
- Whitecap Stainless Heavy Duty Hollow Base Cleat 8in8" · ~1/2" line · 316 stainless steel
- Sea-Dog Heavy Duty Open Base Cleat 10in10" · ~5/8" line · 316 stainless steel
Next guide: Pontoon boat cleats: how many, what size and where
